St. Petersburg · $ · Pizza

Killer Pizza

NY style pizza with a heavy hand and one pie we keep ordering. The Velvet Guillotine.

Last reviewed · July 6, 2026 WebsiteMore in St. Petersburg

The review

Our take

Killer Pizza is our favorite NY style pizza in St Pete. We have not built a whole romance around it. It shows up, we crack the box, and the Velvet Guillotine does what we wanted it to do. Big slice energy, heavy ricotta, maybe a little too much, but not enough to stop us. The crust holds up better than most delivery pizza has any right to. We keep ordering the same pie, which tells the truth faster than another paragraph would.

What stood out

The Velvet Guillotine. Heavy on the ricotta, still the pie we keep ordering.

Our scorecard

Out of five

  • Food4.0/5
  • Taste4.0/5
  • Ambiance3.0/5
  • Service4.0/5
  • Value3.0/5
  • Overall3.6/5

The basics

Find Killer Pizza

Address
1156 94th Avenue NorthSt. Petersburg, FL 33702
Neighborhood
St. Petersburg
Cuisine
Pizza
Price
$

More like this

More pizza in St Pete

See all →