St. Petersburg · $ · Pizza

Killer Pizza

NY style pizza with a heavy hand and one pie we keep ordering. The Velvet Guillotine.

Last reviewed · November 9, 2026 WebsiteMore in St. Petersburg

The review

Our take

Killer Pizza is currently our favorite New York style pizza in St. Pete. It does creative combinations without losing the heart of the pizza.

The pizzas we keep thinking about

The Velvet Guillotine is one of the best pizzas we have had from Killer Pizza. It makes the case for the place pretty fast. It is also not perfect. They go a bit heavy on the ricotta. Not enough to sink it, enough that we noticed it.

We have also had the Sugar and Suffering, which comes with pepperoni, candied jalapeño, and a ghost chili ranch drizzle. We love this one. We get the ranch on the side.

Killer Pizza is not just doing a standard New York pie and then tossing random stuff at it for attention. The combinations feel deliberate. Creative, yes, but still pizza first. That is why it works.

Dining options

They also do delivery through the restaurant’s own site as well as DoorDash and Uber. Dine-in is available too.

The specialty menu keeps the same loud naming style as the pies we tried. Death by Goat has house-made tomato sauce, shredded mozzarella, hickory smoked bacon, fresh basil, and goat cheese crumbles. The Honey Hellfire is has with tomato sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, Genoa salami, chili flakes, and Mike’s Hot Honey.

As far as New York style pizza goes in St. Pete, Killer Pizza is at the top of our list.

What stood out

Creative specialty pies that still feel grounded in New York style pizza, especially The Velvet Guillotine.

Our scorecard

Out of five

  • Food4.0/5
  • Taste4.0/5
  • Ambiance3.0/5
  • Service4.0/5
  • Value3.0/5
  • Overall3.6/5

The basics

Find Killer Pizza

Address
1156 94th Avenue NorthSt. Petersburg, FL 33702
Neighborhood
St. Petersburg
Cuisine
Pizza
Price
$

More like this

More pizza in St Pete

See all →