4th Street North · $$ · Italian

Jay Luigi

Pizza and pasta joint with a Taglio crust that stands out. Nevaeh pizza is the one to remember.

Last reviewed · May 31, 2026 WebsiteMore in 4th Street North

The review

Our take

Jay Luigi gets it right with their pizza. The Taglio crust is thick, almost like Detroit-style, and it's a welcome change from the usual limp pies. Nevaeh pizza is the standout, the one we keep thinking about. Cacio e Pepe didn't disappoint either, which is good when the table wants more than just pizza. It's an easy spot for dinners or casual nights, with a full bar and outdoor seating making it an easy choice. We'd go back just for that crust.

What stood out

The Taglio-style crust. Thick, sturdy, and memorable.

Our scorecard

Out of five

How we score
  • Food4.0/5
  • Taste4.0/5
  • Ambiance4.0/5
  • Service4.0/5
  • Value4.0/5
  • Overall4.0/5

The basics

Find Jay Luigi

Address
3201 4th Street NorthSt. Petersburg, FL 33704
Neighborhood
4th Street North
Cuisine
Italian
Price
$$

Nearby

More in 4th Street North

See all →

More like this

More italian in St Pete

See all →